Zum Hauptinhalt springen

The role of PIDs for secondary publications: More than a technical identifier

diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

Persistent identifiers (PIDs) such as the Digital Object Identifier (DOI) play a crucial role in the publishing industry. They are used to make scientific work clearly identifiable and permanently accessible. Many questions arise in the discussion about the allocation of PIDs for secondary publications – i.e. the re-publication of a previously published work, usually in an open access environment: When does a PID for a secondary publication make sense? How does it affect the impact measurement and the visibility of an author? Here is a look at the most important aspects:

Why a PID for secondary publications?

The assignment of a PID for secondary publications makes it possible to distinguish between different versions of a work. In the scientific field, different versions of the same work, such as the publisher’s version and the author’s version, can be quite relevant. Author’s versions that are uploaded to repositories often differ in layout and format from the publisher’s version, but the content remains the same. A separate PID for the secondary publication allows clean citation without confusion about the source.

In practice, this also helps to solve the problem of findability. Secondary publications are often made available in open access repositories, which are used by researchers to circumvent publishers‘ paywalls. A PID makes these versions more visible and accessible without this being at the expense of the official publisher’s version.

Effect on impact measurement

The measurement of the impact of scientific work is based, among other things, on the number of citations; even if the impact should never be reduced to these quantitative values alone and this reduction has sometimes led to problematic evaluation practices. A PID for secondary publication can have both advantages and disadvantages for citation practice. On the one hand, the existence of an open access version could lead to more scientists accessing and citing the work, as there are no access barriers. On the other hand, the citations could be distributed across two different PIDs – that of the first publication and that of the second publication. This could lead to a fragmentation of the citation impact, unless the citations are correctly linked in the metadata.

To counteract this problem, it is important that the relationships between the first and second publication are clearly labelled in the metadata. PID issuing organisations often offer tools to create such links so that the impact of both versions can be merged. An example of this is the ‘relatedIdentifier’ field in the metadata of the DOI provider DataCite. All PIDs of related resources and other versions can be entered here.

Advantages and possible disadvantages for authors

For authors, the awarding of a PID for secondary publications offers numerous advantages. One major advantage is the increased visibility and accessibility of their work. A secondary publication in Open Access format enables researchers worldwide to access the work without being tied to subscriptions from publishers. This can be particularly advantageous in research areas that are aimed at a broad audience or global collaboration.

Another positive aspect is that authors can share their work in other contexts and with other research groups through secondary publications, which strengthens their networks and reputation. By using a PID, each version of their work remains clearly identifiable and linkable.

However, a potential disadvantage could be that assigning a new PID for the second publication can lead to a split in the citation impact if the two versions are not linked correctly. This can lead to the citations not being fully attributed to the first publication. Authors should therefore ensure that the metadata of their publications clearly reflect the relationship between the versions in order to capture the full impact of their work.

Conclusion: When and why a PID for secondary publications?

Awarding a PID for secondary publications makes sense in many cases, especially if the secondary publication is in an open access repository and thus ensures wider accessibility and dissemination. Authors benefit from the increased visibility, while readers benefit from the easy accessibility. However, in order to avoid possible disadvantages, such as fragmentation of the citation impact, it is crucial that the metadata of the different versions is well maintained and the relationships between first and second publications are correctly labelled.

Overall, the use of PIDs for secondary publications is an important step towards making scientific content easier to find and permanently accessible.


Abonnieren Sie
unsere Newsletter

Newsletter